Bar menu

DISCOVER ITALIAN WINES & COCKTAILS

Carlotto’s beverage program blends modern creativity with classic Italian tradition, featuring a curated wine list highlighting Italy’s best—from iconic regions like Tuscany and Piedmont to hidden gems and rare varietals. Our cocktail menu reinvents Italian classics and includes one of NYC’s most extensive selections of vintage and modern amaro.

View the Full Beverage List

SPRITZES

APEROL SPRITZ
aperol, prosecco, club soda 16

AMARO SPRITZ
amaro lucano, prosecco, club soda 15

SBAGLIATO
campari, carpano antica, prosecco 15

CARLOTTO’S WAY
almatitan blanco tequila, aperol, preserved lemon cordial, club soda  19

COCKTAILS

MR BOND MARTINI
sipsmith gin, haku vodka, cocchi americano, lillet blanc 22

SOLARI
absolute vanilla vodka, chinola passionfruit liqueur, prosecco 22

‘PARADISO’ MARGARITA
absolut vanilla vodka, chinola passionfruit liqueur, prosecco 22

CALYPSO
ten to one dark rum, prickly pear puree, juliette peach liqueur, pink peppercorn, lemon 19

SANDBAR
arette blanco tequila, herring cherry, allspice dram, orgeat, fee foam 21

TEABALL
toki suntory whisky, mirto verde, earl grey, peychaud bitters 23

PIGLET
piggyback 6yr rye or bourbon, whistle pig maple shrub,  Biggallet china china, orchard street bitters  29

LA PRIMA 
old particular craigellachie 13yr single malt, lemon, fee foam, bitters 25

NEGRONIS

CLASSICO
silvio carta ‘gillo’ gin, campari, bordiga vermouth di torino  19

BIANCO
the botanist gin, amara d’arancia, cocchi americano bianco  18

ROSA
barhill gin, fred jerbis bitter, cocchi rosa, istine vermouth  18

RUM
ten to one dark rum, amaro lucano, campari  18

MEZCAL
agua magica mezcal, carpano antica, campari, lillet blanc  20

BOULEVARDIER
taconic cabernet cask bourbon, mulassano bitter, marolo rosso  20

BEER

DRAUGHT

Pilsner – / Wild East / ‘L’Ultima Moda’, New York 4.8% 12

IPA – Hazy East Coast / Other Half / Green City, New York 7% 12

BEER BOTTLE / CAN

Menabrea – Lager / Menabrea / Italy 4.8% 10

Glutenberg / Glutenberg, Canada 5.5% (Gluten-Free)  14

Wheat Beer – Witbier / Hitachino Nest White Ale, Japan 5.5%  18

IPA – Sour / Hudson Valley / Peach Silhouette, New York 5%  16

Porter / Greenport Harbor / ‘Black Duck’, New York 4.7%   14

Cider / Wolffer Estate / ‘Rose Cider’, New York 6.9%   14